Auto-Enrolment Pension Costs: The Line Bids Forget
- Published
- Author
- Mian Khubaib Jim
- Reading time
- 9 min
- Topic
- auto enrolment cost per hour

Pension is the smallest statutory line in a cleaning bid. That is why it gets forgotten. The auto enrolment cost per hour is not 3 per cent of the wage. It depends on a band of earnings and a weekly trigger and whether the operative stays in the scheme. And the rules are under review by a commission that reports in 2027.
This blog is a small research paper. One question. The published data that answers it. The finding. And what it means for the person pricing the next contract. Every figure comes from a named source or is calculated in a numbered table.
Key Findings#
- 3 per cent is never 3 per cent. On qualifying earnings the employer minimum is 1.23 per cent of pay for a 16 hour operative and 2.24 per cent at 37.5 hours. Per productive hour that is £0.18 to £0.32 [1][2].
- A 15 hour operative is 6 minutes from the trigger. Weekly pay of £190.65 sits £1.35 under the £192 weekly trigger. One cover shift makes them eligible for enrolment that week [1][3].
- Opt out is small and does not last. About 90 per cent of eligible employees save and opt out is below 11 per cent. Every three years employers must put leavers back in [4][5][3].
- Removing the lower limit adds 61 per cent. Contributions from the first pound would add £187.20 a year per operative. That is 1.01 per cent of employment cost on a 25 hour operative against 0.1 per cent across the economy [6].
- The sector pays the minimum. Workers in administrative and support services are 26 points more likely than those in manufacturing to receive only the 3 per cent employer minimum [6].
1. The Question#
What pension cost should a cleaning bid carry per hour once the qualifying earnings band and the weekly trigger and opt out and possible reform are all taken into account?
The rules look simple. Employers pay at least 3 per cent of qualifying earnings and the total minimum is 8 per cent [2]. Qualifying earnings run from £6240 to £50270 a year and the earnings trigger is £10000 [1]. The detail sits in the pay periods. Weekly paid operatives are measured against £120 and £192 every week.
2. The Data and the Method#
Table 1. Sources used and what each one answers
Ref | Source | What it contains | Used for |
1.1 | The Pensions Regulator thresholds [1] | £120 and £192 and £967 a week for 2026 to 2027 | Band and trigger |
1.2 | The Pensions Regulator contributions [2] | 3 per cent employer and 8 per cent total | Contribution rate |
1.3 | The Pensions Regulator ongoing duties [3] | Check every pay run and re enrol every three years | Duties |
1.4 | DWP participation statistics 2025 [4] | 90 per cent of eligible employees saving | Opt out |
1.5 | Second Pensions Commission interim report [5] | Opt out below 11 per cent and a final report in 2027 | Reform timing |
1.6 | Institute for Fiscal Studies July 2026 [6] | Minimum contributions by industry and reform costs | Benchmark |
1.7 | Operify AI series [7][8] | Contract and loaded cost figures | Self citations |
Operatives are paid the National Living Wage of £12.71 [9] for 52 weeks and work 46.4 so cost is divided by productive hours. Every operative is assumed to be aged 22 or over. The contract figures use the illustrative contract of 24960 productive hours a year with a margin of £24000 [7]. At 25 hours a week that is 21.52 operatives.
3. What the Data Shows#
3.1 Three Per Cent Is Never Three Per Cent#
Table 2. Employer pension by weekly hours at the National Living Wage
Ref | Hours a week | Weekly pay | Status by weekly pay | Employer minimum a year | Share of pay | Per productive hour |
2.1 | 8 | £101.68 | Below the band | None required | 0.00 per cent | £0.00 |
2.2 | 12 | £152.52 | May opt in | £50.73 if they join | 0.64 per cent | £0.09 |
2.3 | 15 | £190.65 | May opt in | £110.21 if they join | 1.11 per cent | £0.16 |
2.4 | 16 | £203.36 | Must be enrolled | £130.04 | 1.23 per cent | £0.18 |
2.5 | 20 | £254.20 | Must be enrolled | £209.35 | 1.58 per cent | £0.23 |
2.6 | 25 | £317.75 | Must be enrolled | £308.49 | 1.87 per cent | £0.27 |
2.7 | 30 | £381.30 | Must be enrolled | £407.63 | 2.06 per cent | £0.29 |
2.8 | 37.5 | £476.63 | Must be enrolled | £556.34 | 2.24 per cent | £0.32 |
Calculated. Employer minimum is 3 per cent of annual pay above £6240. Status uses the weekly thresholds of £120 and £192 for workers aged 22 or over.
A flat 3 per cent on the wage is 38 pence a paid hour at £12.71. The real figure never reaches it because the first £6240 of the pay of each operative is outside the band. The £0.27 for a 25 hour operative is the pension line in the series loaded hour [8].
3.2 The Weekly Trigger and the Cover Shift#
Employers must check age and earnings every time they pay staff and enrol anyone who crosses the trigger within six weeks [3]. A 15 hour operative earns £190.65 a week. That is £1.35 or about 6 minutes of pay below the £192 weekly trigger [1].
One extra 4 hour cover shift takes that week to £241.49. The operative becomes eligible for automatic enrolment. Once in the scheme the employer pays 3 per cent of every pound above £120 a week. At their normal 15 hours that is £2.12 a week or £110.21 a year that was never in the bid. A bid that priced its 15 hour operatives at zero pension and filled its cover from the same people has priced a line that will not stay at zero.
3.3 Opt Out Is Small and Temporary#
Around 90 per cent of eligible employees saved into a workplace pension in 2025 [4]. The Second Pensions Commission puts opt out below 11 per cent [5]. Every three years employers must put staff who have left the scheme back in [3].
On the illustrative contract 21.52 operatives at £308.49 is £6639 a year of employer pension. Pricing 11 per cent opt out would save £730. That saving lasts until the next re enrolment date and most contracts run longer than three years. It is a cash flow effect and not a pricing assumption.
3.4 What Reform Could Add#
The Commission will make final recommendations in 2027 and says any change to contribution rates would not come in the current parliament [5]. The IFS has modelled the options [6]. Two matter most for cleaning.
Table 3. Employer pension under two reform options
Ref | Option | 16 hours | 25 hours | 37.5 hours |
3.1 | Today at 3 per cent above £6240 | £130.04 | £308.49 | £556.34 |
3.2 | 3 per cent from the first pound | £317.24 | £495.69 | £743.54 |
3.3 | Increase per operative | £187.20 | £187.20 | £187.20 |
3.4 | Increase as share of employment cost | 1.62 per cent | 1.01 per cent | 0.66 per cent |
3.5 | 6 per cent from the first pound | £634.48 | £991.38 | £1487.07 |
3.6 | Increase as share of employment cost | 4.37 per cent | 3.68 per cent | 3.29 per cent |
Modelled at current rates with no behavioural change. Employment cost is pay plus employer NI plus employer pension today. These are options under review and not announced policy.
Removing the lower limit adds a flat £187.20 per operative whatever their hours. So it hits short hours hardest. The IFS puts the economy wide cost of that change together with extending eligibility to age 18 at 0.1 per cent of total remuneration [6]. For a 25 hour cleaning operative the lower limit alone is 1.01 per cent which is ten times the average. The IFS also finds that higher minimum contributions raise employer costs most in industries where many workers are close to the minimum wage [6]. On the illustrative contract 21.52 operatives at £187.20 is £4029 a year or 16.8 per cent of the margin. The 6 per cent option would take £14696 or 61.2 per cent.
4. What It Means for a Contractor#
- Price on qualifying earnings. Never 3 per cent of the wage and never zero.
- Treat short hours as future members. A cover shift can enrol a 15 hour operative in one week.
- Do not bank opt out. Re enrolment every three years brings most of it back.
- Test long bids against reform. Contracts that run into the next parliament should show the cost of removing the lower limit.
- Ask for inherited rates. Operatives arriving under TUPE may carry contributions above the minimum.
The pension line is part of the cost per hour worked and it moves with the shift pattern. Short patterns carry less pension until a cover week pushes an operative over the trigger. Operatives inherited under TUPE bring their existing pension terms so ask before pricing. In Operify AI the scheduling and roster module records every claimed open shift so extra hours are visible before the payroll run that turns them into a pension duty.
5. What This Does Not Show#
- Everyone is assumed to be 22 or over. Younger workers and those over state pension age are not automatically enrolled.
- Pay is at the wage floor. Higher pay moves every figure.
- Reform figures are options. Nothing in Table 3 is announced policy and the Commission reports in 2027.
- Some employers pay more. Schemes above the minimum and inherited TUPE terms raise the line.
- The contract is illustrative. 24960 hours a year is a model and not a customer.
6. Conclusion#
The pension line in a cleaning bid runs from nothing to 32 pence a productive hour depending on the pattern. It is small. It is also unstable. A cover shift can enrol a part timer in a week. Opt out returns to the scheme every three years. And the lower limit that keeps the line small is under review.
A bid that prices pension on the band and the real pattern carries the right number today. A bid that also shows the reform options tells the client what a five year contract may cost in year four.
References#
[1] The Pensions Regulator. Earnings thresholds 2026 to 2027. Lower level £120 a week or £6240 a year. Trigger £192 a week or £10000 a year. Upper level £967 a week or £50270 a year. Available at Pensions Regulator earnings thresholds (accessed October 2026).
[2] The Pensions Regulator. Making contributions to your pension scheme. Employer minimum 3 per cent and total minimum 8 per cent of qualifying earnings. Available at pension contributions guidance (accessed October 2026).
[3] The Pensions Regulator. Your ongoing duties and re enrolment. Monitor ages and earnings every time you pay staff. Enrol within six weeks of meeting the criteria. Put leavers back in every three years. Available at ongoing duties and re enrolment (accessed October 2026).
[4] Department for Work and Pensions. Workplace pension participation and savings trends of employees 2009 to 2025. Published 30 July 2026. 90 per cent of eligible employees saving in 2025. Available at DWP participation statistics (accessed October 2026).
[5] Second Pensions Commission. Pensions 2050 Evidence and Future Priorities. Interim report. Opt out below 11 per cent. Final recommendations in 2027 and no change to contribution rates in the current parliament. Available at Second Pensions Commission interim report (accessed October 2026).
[6] Cribb J and Karjalainen H and OBrien L. Automatic enrolment. Trends in employer pension contributions and the impact of potential reforms. Institute for Fiscal Studies. 21 July 2026. Independent research. Scenario A removes the lower limit of qualifying earnings and extends eligibility to age 18 at a cost of 0.1 per cent of total remuneration. Workers in administrative and support services are 26 percentage points more likely than those in manufacturing to receive only the statutory minimum after controlling for sex and age and earnings and employer size. Available at IFS automatic enrolment report (accessed October 2026).
[7] Operify AI. CAI/GR/001/OPI. Losing Money in Plain Sight. Guides and Research series. Self citation. Illustrative contract of 24960 hours a year with a 5 per cent margin of £24000. Model.
[8] Operify AI. CAI/GR/003/OPI. The Loaded Cost of an Operative Hour 2026. Guides and Research series. Self citation. Pension line of £0.27 per productive hour for a 25 hour operative. Calculation.
[9] UK Government. National Minimum Wage and National Living Wage rates. £12.71 an hour from April 2026. Available at National Living Wage rates (accessed October 2026).
About Operify AI#
We sell tender costing and rostering software. That is a commercial interest in this finding and readers should weigh it. Two things constrain it. Every threshold and rate is published and named so any reader can rerun the arithmetic. Section 5 states what the figures do not show.
Operify AI is operated by Codedevza AI Ltd company number 16485057. Correspondence to hello@operifyai.co.uk.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the auto enrolment thresholds for 2026 to 2027?
Qualifying earnings from £6240 to £50270 a year and a £10000 trigger. Weekly that is £120 and £967 with a £192 trigger.
Is the employer contribution 3 per cent of pay?
No. It is 3 per cent of qualifying earnings. For a 25 hour operative that is 1.87 per cent of pay.
What does auto enrolment cost per productive hour?
At the wage floor about £0.18 at 16 hours and £0.27 at 25 hours and £0.32 at 37.5 hours.
Can a part time operative become eligible in one week?
Yes. Employers check earnings every pay run. A 15 hour operative is £1.35 below the weekly trigger so one cover shift can make them eligible.
Should a bid assume staff opt out?
No. Opt out is below 11 per cent and employers must re enrol leavers every three years.
What is the Second Pensions Commission?
A government commission reviewing pension adequacy. Its final recommendations are due in 2027.
What if contributions started from the first pound?
Each operative would cost £187.20 a year more at 3 per cent. For a 25 hour operative that is a 61 per cent rise in the pension line.
Do cleaning firms usually pay more than the minimum?
Less often than most. IFS research found workers in administrative and support services 26 points more likely to receive only the minimum than those in manufacturing.
Does postponement reduce the cost?
Only for up to three months. It moves the cost and does not remove it so keep it out of the contract price.
How much does Operify AI cost?
Pricing is built around operatives and sites and the modules taken rather than a per head licence so cost stays steady through turnover. The figure is given on the demo call. See pricing or email hello@operifyai.co.uk.
auto enrolment cost per hour